Never Quit Looking — Case File
Missing Person
Case ID#: 0056
VICTIM’S PHOTOGRAPH
Missing
Stacy Kathleen McCall
May Also Be Known As: N/A
Unidentified Person Notice: In English, unidentified individuals are often known as “Jane Doe” or “John Doe.” This means the victim’s true name is currently unknown.
Biological Sex: Female
Age at the Time: 18
Country: United States of America
Date Missing: June 7, 1992
Brief Overview: The Springfield Three: Sherrill Levitt, Suzie Streeter, and Stacy McCall mysteriously vanished from a Missouri Residence leaving no trace.
Public Awareness Notice: This case file is provided for public awareness and responsible information sharing. If you have relevant information, please contact the appropriate law enforcement agency.
Victim Description
Physical Description
Date of Birth
April 23, 1974
Age
18
Age Group
Teenager (13 to 19 Years Old)
Biological Sex
Female
Hair Color
Long, Blonde Hair
Eye Color
Blue
Ethnicity
Caucasian or White
Nationality
United States
Language(s) Spoken
English
Physical Build
Height (ft’ in”)
5'3"
Height (cm)
160 cm
Weight (lbs)
120 lbs
Weight (kg)
54.4 kg
Distinguishing Features
Medical Condition
Migraines with Medication
Piercing(s)
Ear
Clothing & Accessories
Clothing
Description
- Floral bikini underwear
- Yellow Shirt
Possessions & Accessories
Description
- 14″ Gold Necklace (Herringbone)
- Gold Ring with her Initials
- Small Diamond Ring
Description of Events
Disappearance
Date Last Seen
June 7, 1992
The Incident
On June 7, 1992, high school graduates Suzanne Streeter (19) and Stacy McCall (18) attended graduation parties around Springfield, Missouri. Originally planning to spend the night at a hotel, the girls ultimately decided to stay at Streeter’s home, which she shared with her mother, Sherrill Levitt (47). By the following morning, all three women had vanished without a trace from the Levitt residence.
Friends who came by the house that day reported strange details: all three women’s purses, keys, and cars were at the house, as were the women’s personal belongings. The glass light cover on the porch was shattered, and a friend even cleaned it up, not realizing it might be evidence. The family dog, Cinnamon, was still there, seemingly distressed. Despite these oddities, there were no clear signs of a struggle inside the home. Over time, police efforts to find them included excavations and hundreds of interviews, but no solid leads ever panned out.
Numerous theories have been proposed—from abduction to murder to being victims of a serial killer—but to this day, there has been no definitive evidence to explain what happened.
Multiple Victims?
Yes
Rumored & Potential Sightings
A server reported having seen the three women (Sherrill, Stacy, and Suzanne) at George’s Steakhouse (339 S Glenstone Ave) sometime between 2:20am – 3:00am. This would put them a couple of minutes away from Levitt’s home. Suzie was reportedly under the influence. This Has NOT Been Substantiated By The Police.
A tipster also reportedly saw a green van driven by a woman matching Suzie’s description at 6:30am – 7:00am. The tipster also reported overhearing a male voice speaking threateningly to the driver. This Has NOT Been Substantiated By The Police.
Additional details
Related Vehicle
Description
- Sherrill Levitt’s Mitsubishi Eclipse (Blue)
- Suzanne Streeter’s Ford Escort (Red)
- Stacy McCall’s Toyota Corolla (Red)
- Grey-green Dodge Van
- (1964-1970) Brown Dodge Van with a Rusted Bottom
- Blue Van with a Camper Top
Places of Interest
Disappearance
Street Address
1717 E. Delmar Street
City
Springfield
State or Province
Missouri
Country
United States of America
Postal Code (Zip Code)
65804
Latitude & Longitude
37.1949267,-93.2873471
General Location
Town or City
Map of Other Key Locations
Photo Gallery
Related or Similar Cases
Suzanne Elizabeth Streeter
Relationship: Suzanne’s high school classmate and friend. Sherrill’s daughter. The two girls were spending the night at Suzanne’s home when all three women disappeared.
Case ID#: 0057
Sherrill Elizabeth Levitt
Relationship: Suzanne’s mother. She was home with Suzanne and Stacy when all three women disappeared.
Case ID#: 0055
Resources
Articles & Other Written Works
- Bauer, L. (2002) “Webster Country Digging to Begin”, Springfield News Leader, 3 August
- Bryan, B. (1993) “Van May Yield Clues in Case of Missing Women”, St. Louis Post Dispatch, 31 October.
- Clauser B. (1992) Springfield News Leader, 5 December.
- Fruen, L. (2019) ‘Police Reveal New Leads in 1992 Case of the Springfield Three‘, Daily Mail, 23 October.
- Goldman, K. (2017) ‘Crime Watch Daily Investigates the Mysterious Disappearance of the Springfield Three’, True Crime Daily, 17 October.
- Gounley, T. (2017) “25 Years After Three Springfield Women Went Missing, The Tips Still Trickle In”, Springfield News Leader, 30 May
- Investigation Discovery (2011) “The Springfield Three“, [Disappeared], Season 3: Episode 10. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B004R146YE/ref=atv_feed_catalog?tag=imdb-amazonvideo-20
- Joshua A. Tepfer, Laura H. Nirider & Lynda M. Tricarico, Arresting Development: Convictions of Innocent Youth, 62 RUTGERS L. REV. 887 (2010).
- Keegan, H (2019) “Family Says Tennessee Charges Against Three Missing Women Relative Were ‘Exaggerated‘”, Springfield News Leader, 21 March.
- Lemieux, J. (1992) “Search goes on for three women missing from Springfield, MO”, St. Louis Post Dispatch, 9 August.
- McCall, J. (N.D.) Surviving Parents Coalition. http://www.spcoalition.org/mccall.html
- Nachtigal, J. (1993) “Graduation-Day Disappearance of 3 MO. Women Remains Unsolved a Year Later”, The Sun, 9 June
- Nachtigal, J. (1993) “Anguish but No Answers a Year After 3 Women’s Disappearance Crime”, Los Angeles Times, 13 June.
- No Author (1992) “Three Vanish; Police and Family Fear Foul Play”, St. Louis Post Dispatch, 9 June
- No Author (1992) “Mother, Daughter Vanish With Friend; Police Baffled”, Orlando Sentinel, 13 June.
- No Author (1993) “Whereabouts of 3 Women Still a Mystery”, Orlando Sentinel, 13 June.
- No Author (1993) “Police Search Farm, Won’t Give Reason”, St. Louis Post Dispatch, 30 August
- No Author (1995) “1,000 Days and No Sign of 3 Women”, St. Louis Post-Dispatch, 24 February.
- No Author (2002) “Our View”, Springfield News Leader, 3 June.
- No Author (2002) “Case of 3 Missing Women Baffles Authorities”, Los Angeles Times, 9 June.
- No Author (2006) “I’m Not a Monster”, Springfield News Leader, 9 June
- No Author (2006) “Missing-women Case May Break”, Springfield News Leader, 9 June
- Pasqualini, K. (2019) “Springfield 3: best Friends and Mother Missing in Missouri”, Medium, 15 October.
- Rollins, J. (2010) “Missing Poster Still Hangs 18 Years Later”, Springfield News Leader, 3 December.
- Springfield Police (2015) “Three Missing Women”, https://www.springfieldmo.gov/2498/Three-Missing-Women.
- Story of the Unsolved (2018) ‘The Disappearance of the Springfield Three”, 24 December.
- Strait, J. (2002) “Tip Proves Fruitless In Missing Women Case”, Springfield News Leader, 5 August
- Streeter Family Blog, http://streeterfamilyblogg.blogspot.com/p/person-of-interest.html
- Uhlenbrok, T. (1992) “Disappearance of 3 Women Baffles Police; No Clues: Abduction Suspected”, St. Louis Post Dispatch, 14 June.
- Warren, D. (2015) The Springfield Three, Lulu.com.
- Wise County (1995), “Former Death Row Inmate Sentenced to Life in Prison – Cuts Write Before Punishment Phase of Trial”, Wise County, August 11, http://www.wisecounty.com/themuse/PressRelease2.htm
Podcasts
- Creepytime, “Ep. 74 – Three Women Disappear From the Same Home in ONe Night” (Link)
- Ozarks True Crime, “The Springfield Three Ep. 1: Graduation Night and the Disappearance of Stacy, Suzie, and Sherrill, (Link).
- Housewives of True Crime, “Vanishing in Springfield: The Mystery of the Missing Three (Suzanne “Suzie” Streeter, Stacy McCall, and Sherrill Levitt), (Link).
- Inhuman: A True Crime Podcast, “Episode 39: The Springfield Three Part 1, (Link)
- Mile Higher, “93: Unsolved Disappearance of the Springfield Three”, (Link)
- Voices for Justice, “The Springfield Three”, (Link)
- The Generation Why, “The Springfield Three – 258”, (Link)
- American Hauntings Podcast, “The Vanishing of the Springfield Three”, (Link)
- Red Web, “Springfield Three”, (Link).
- Wife of Crime, “Vanished – The Springfield 3”, (Link).
- True Crime Garage, “Springfield Three / / / Part 2 / / / 98”, (Link).
- Crime Weekly, “S2 Ep 87: The Springfield Three: Gone Without a Trace (Part 1), (Link).
Contact Authorities
Police, Relevant Agencies, & Other Useful Personnel
Important Notice
This page is not intended for emergency use. Contact details may change over time, and the information listed below may be outdated or incomplete. If you notice an error or have a correction, please let us know.
To the best of our ability, we have provided contact information for the national police agency or, where that is not available, the police agency serving the capital city. Our hope is that these agencies may be able to direct readers to the proper office, even when a matter falls outside their immediate jurisdiction.
For the most accurate guidance, please contact the relevant embassy in your country or your own country’s embassy or consulate in the country involved.
Contact Information — United States of America
Agency 🏢
Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)
Phone Number 📞
Emergency Phone Number 🚨
Website 💻
Email Address 📧
IDD Prefix
011
Country Code
+1
Additional Contacts
- National Crime Information Center (NCIC) — Website
- Crime Stoppers USA — Locate a Program
- National Center for Missing & Exploited Children (NCMEC) — Website
- National Missing and Unidentified Persons System (NamUs) — Website
Join The Conversation!
The Suitcase Detective is a growing global archive of mystery and investigation content, including true crime case files, detective literature, films, television series, and radio and podcast storytelling. Follow us as we document, preserve, and connect the stories behind the mysteries.
Disclaimer & Content Warning
Please read with care. This case file may contain sensitive details, images, or references involving missing persons, unidentified persons, unsolved homicides, or other unresolved cases. Some readers may find this material upsetting. All readers access and use these case files at their own discretion.
Information on this page is gathered from publicly available sources, including official notices, law enforcement or government releases, NGOs, news reports, blogs, and other media. It is provided for general informational and awareness purposes only. The Suitcase Detective and Never Quit Looking make no warranties regarding the accuracy, validity, availability, timeliness, or completeness of any information included here.
Under no circumstances shall The Suitcase Detective, Never Quit Looking, or their owners, contributors, or affiliates be liable for any loss, harm, misunderstanding, or other issue arising from the use of this information. Continued use of this website constitutes acceptance of our Privacy Policy, Terms & Conditions, and applicable disclaimers.
If you reference or share information from this page, please include a direct link back to the original case file so readers can review the source context and access any future updates.